F45 Loses Its Non-Compete but Wins on Member Poaching

Ontario's top court said ex-franchisees who courted 300 F45 members for a rival gym broke a reasonable non-solicit clause, even as it tossed the broader non-compete.

2 min read
ShareXLinkedIn
Osgoode Hall in Toronto, home of the Court of Appeal for Ontario
Source: Law Times

The franchisees expected 98% of their 300 members to follow them to a new gym. That number, from their own funding request, is what sank them.

On Nov. 3, the Court of Appeal for Ontario ruled in F45 Training Canada Limited v. 2685802 Ontario Limited that the former owners of an F45 studio in Whitby, Ontario, broke the non-solicitation clause in their franchise agreement when they courted members for The Yard Gym. In the same decision, the court threw out F45's non-compete clause as unreasonable.

The owners signed a five-year F45 agreement in March 2019 and opened F45 Whitby West in a mall that November. In October 2024 they told F45 they would not renew, signed with The Yard Gym and extended the mall lease. While the F45 studio was still open, they emailed and texted its members inviting them to convert to The Yard Gym at their current F45 rate, according to a summary of the decision by Blaney McMurtry.

A Superior Court judge refused to enforce either clause in March 2025, finding both too ambiguous. The appeal panel, in reasons by Justice Katherine van Rensburg, said she read the wording in isolation instead of in the context of the whole agreement, Law Times reported.

Then the court split the result. The non-compete covered a broad range of fitness work, including group classes devoted solely to things like dance, yoga or outdoor exercise. That reached past F45's legitimate interest, which the court framed as a one-stop group fitness system, Gardiner Roberts noted. The non-solicit was narrower. Read alongside clauses giving F45 ownership of the studio's goodwill and member information, it simply barred the owners from using that customer data for a competing studio in the same market.

The court found the owners breached it, but sent the extent of the breach and the remedy back to the Superior Court. The clause ran until November 2026.

Here is what I would take from this if I drafted franchise agreements. The covenant that survived was tied to something the franchisor could show it owned: the member list. The one that died tried to fence off a whole category of work.

U.S. pressure runs the same direction. Virginia has banned post-term non-competes in new franchise agreements since July 1, and earlier this month a Tampa judge ruled against a Rumble franchisee who rebranded his gyms.

For F45, which has been trading unit count for stronger franchisees, the ruling confirms its member data is its own. It does not give the brand any say over who runs a gym at that mall address.

Jordan Reyes
Editor in Chief
Related

More coverage to read

The Brief

Practical AI and franchise growth intelligence, in your inbox

One focused read for operators and brand builders. No fluff, no daily noise.

Join operators and franchise leaders reading every week.