California Says Many Franchise Contracts Break Its Law

State regulators flagged backdoor vendor fees, gag clauses and noncompetes after reviewing agreements used nationwide, and warned they can block franchise sales in California.

2 min read
ShareXLinkedIn
Overhead view of a marked-up contract with red pen lines, sticky flags and reading glasses on a desk
Source: Revscale Media (illustration)

California's franchise regulator read a stack of franchise agreements used around the country and came back with a list of clauses it considers illegal.

The Department of Financial Protection and Innovation said Nov. 20 that a review of agreements used across multiple states found many with provisions that may violate state law, and it issued guidance naming the problem terms. The agency framed the timing plainly: the guidance comes "as federal regulators continue to roll back enforcement of franchise protections."

First on the list is what DFPI calls backdoor fees. Rather than disclose every required payment, some franchisors make franchisees buy from particular services or vendors "at inflated prices that benefit the franchisor," the agency said. Nation's Restaurant News reported that the guidance links those markups to rebates flowing back to franchisors. It is the same ground covered by the class action over Toast, which tests what franchisees can do when a brand mandates its technology vendor.

Second are gag orders: contract language that discourages franchisees from reporting wrongdoing to law enforcement or limits what they can say about working with a franchisor. Third are restraints on trade. DFPI reminded franchisors that their agreements are subject to California law on restraints of "a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind," which NRN read as the agency saying noncompetes are not legal even inside franchise contracts. Courts elsewhere are drawing similar lines; in Ontario, an appeals court recently struck an F45 franchisee's non-compete while upholding a ban on poaching members.

None of this is new law. AB 676, signed in 2022, lets the commissioner issue a stop order when a franchise agreement "contains a provision that is contrary to law," and it voids clauses that make franchisees disclaim what a franchisor told them. What changed on Friday is that the regulator spelled out which clauses it will treat that way.

The enforcement tool is registration. DFPI said it can block a franchise from being sold in the state and deny or cancel its registration, and it pointed to recent cases, including a franchisor that concealed how many of its locations had closed and another with 48 violations involving unregistered sales, missing disclosures and recordkeeping. NRN tied those actions to Dickey's Barbecue Pit and The Kickin' Crab.

For franchisors, the practical question is what happens at their next filing, now that the reviewer has published what it is looking for. For franchisees in California, the guidance is a reference point if a supplier markup or a confidentiality clause ever lands in a dispute.

It also arrives while Congress is stuck on franchising's other big question. The American Franchise Act, the joint-employer bill, lost its House floor slot this week and is short on lame-duck days. California is not waiting on Washington.

Priya Shah
Senior Reporter
Related

More coverage to read

The Brief

Practical AI and franchise growth intelligence, in your inbox

One focused read for operators and brand builders. No fluff, no daily noise.

Join operators and franchise leaders reading every week.