Distressed Restaurants Are Piling Up. Fewer Buyers Want Them.

At this week's restaurant finance conference, bankers said half the buyer base is gone, while operators who buy broken stores described what fixing them really costs.

4 min read
ShareXLinkedIn
Exterior of a Denny's restaurant against a clear sky
Source: Franchise Times

Clyde Rucker assumes the seller's numbers are wrong.

Not dishonest, necessarily. Just optimistic. Rucker, CEO of Rucker Restaurant Holdings, runs 51 Denny's and 57 Jack in the Box restaurants across Florida and Texas, and he built part of that portfolio by buying restaurants other people couldn't make work. When he looks at a struggling franchised store, he told a panel at the Restaurant Finance & Development Conference in Las Vegas this week, both the sales and the price tag to fix the place are often inaccurate, Franchise Times reported.

"The franchisor will have minimum requirements," Rucker said. "But the way we operate is we don't want to do the minimum because we're not going to get the maximum return. So, we typically go in assuming we've got to put in a significant amount of CapX in to make the improvements."

That is the supply side of the restaurant deal market right now: plenty of stores for sale, many of them tired. From the same conference stage, the demand side looked a lot thinner.

"Investors that were so active in the market in 2018, 2019, their portfolios are chock full of brands," Ashish Seth, founder of Harrington Park Advisors, said, according to Nation's Restaurant News. "They can't exit for one reason or the other. Maybe it's performance. Maybe it's not the valuation they want. So 50%, 60% of the buyer base has just evaporated."

Cristin O'Hara, head of restaurants for Bank of America, supplied the other half of the explanation. "Fewer private-equity firms have been interested in the restaurant space because they're getting outsized gains in other areas," she said. Franchisors can still find buyers, NRN reported, because investors like their low cost of capital and more predictable cash flow. It is restaurant operating companies that are stuck.

Underneath both problems sits traffic. Victor Fernandez, chief insights officer at Black Box Intelligence, told attendees that industry same-store sales are tracking up 1.7% this year, with average check doing all the work. Traffic at the chains Black Box tracks is down 21% since 2018, Vinetur noted in its writeup of his remarks. "That's a lot," Fernandez said.

Put those pieces together and you get the season we have been covering. A franchisee runs short of guests and cash, the buyer pool is thin, and the stores end up with the franchisor or in front of a judge. Wendy's has offered about $46 million as the opening bid for 163 Meritage restaurants. Denny's said it wants other franchisees in its system to take over a failed 30-unit operator's stores. Bloomin' Brands lined up as the stalking horse bidder when an Outback franchisee with 61 restaurants filed for bankruptcy, Franchise Times reported.

Which brings it back to the people on Rucker's panel: the operators who actually want those stores, and what they say it takes.

Roland Spongberg, founder and CEO of WKS Restaurant Group, has been buying distressed restaurants for more than three decades. WKS now has 382 units in 20 states across Denny's, El Pollo Loco, Krispy Kreme and Wendy's. Troubled stores, he said, usually fail for one of three reasons. "It could be operations, it could be the balance sheet with an inability to keep the restaurant in good shape and it could be a people issue," Spongberg said.

His example was a purchase of 54 struggling Wendy's restaurants in California, with average unit volumes well below the company average and most needing remodels. "You can't fix 54 Wendy's in a short period of time," he said. One store, you can drop in your own general manager. Fifty-four, you keep the people you inherited. WKS remodeled while it retrained the existing crews, and the work took years. Once the remodels were done, Spongberg said, average unit volumes went from $1.5 million to $2.2 million.

Rucker's clock for a single store is shorter: two to three weeks of construction, 30 to 45 days of stabilization, and usually in good shape by 90 days. He still warned newcomers off. He doesn't recommend buying distressed restaurants as a way to become a franchisee. "You need the experience to make the business work," he said.

Jeb Ball, managing director at Guideboat Advisors, added a caution that cuts the other way. Look hard at the brand, not just the seller. "There are problems that franchisees have that are the results of actions taken by the brand itself," Ball said. When a sale runs through bankruptcy, he added, buyers should expect a court process on a strict timeline, with the benefit of more transparency.

For a franchisee thinking about selling next year, the math is unforgiving. With fewer financial buyers, the likeliest bidder is another operator in the same system, someone who will price in a remodel, assume the sales figures are soft and walk away if the brand is the problem. NRN's summary of the bankers' advice was plain: deals still get done for good operators and good brands, but sellers need to be "realistic" about valuations.

So here is the open question heading into 2027. If half the financial buyers are gone and traffic keeps sliding, how many struggling stores find an operator like Rucker or Spongberg before they find a bankruptcy court? Our column last week asked what franchisors do when a franchisee fails. In Las Vegas, the buyers told sellers what it will cost them.

Jordan Reyes
Editor in Chief
Related

More coverage to read

The Brief

Practical AI and franchise growth intelligence, in your inbox

One focused read for operators and brand builders. No fluff, no daily noise.

Join operators and franchise leaders reading every week.