In six weeks, a Korean franchisor that refuses to sit down with an organized group of its own franchisees could face a corrective order from the government.
Korea's Fair Trade Commission said Nov. 16 that its registration system for franchisee associations takes effect Dec. 31 under the amended Franchise Business Act, Signal reported. A group can register if it includes at least 10% of a brand's franchisees, or at least 1,000 members, and clears a minimum membership floor. Registered groups can ask the franchisor to negotiate changes to contract terms. A franchisor that refuses without justifiable grounds faces a corrective order.
The draft rules spell out how that works. According to a Kim & Chang summary of the commission's August notice, a registered group can request talks in writing on matters such as required franchise agreement terms and advertising and promotion. The franchisor must start within 14 days, hold at least two meetings, keep minutes for three years and tell franchisees who did not take part how it went. A group that finishes talks cannot reopen the same topic for 180 days.
The fight has been over the threshold. Under the draft, a group needs at least 30 members, which shuts out brands with fewer than 30 outlets and forces small systems to organize well above 10%, The Herald Business reported in September. Commission chair Joo Byung-ki said then that he was weighing a lower floor. "I am aware of concerns that registration requirements place a heavier burden on store owners belonging to small franchisors," he said, according to SBS. Franchisor groups pushed the other way, asking for a higher participation rate.
The deal market is paying attention. Global investors are the biggest buyers of Korean franchise companies, and the head of one global private equity firm said, according to Signal, that the potential for disputes with franchisees is weighing on acquisitions. Mom's Touch is on the block, and Burger King, Frank Burger and Norang Tongdak are being considered mainly by overseas buyers, Signal reported. The pressure point is profit: supply prices on required items and how ad costs get split. Earlier this year, Korea's Supreme Court upheld a partial win for 94 Pizza Hut Korea franchisees who sued over supply margins, and similar refund suits have spread to other chains and convenience stores.
U.S. franchisees have no equivalent right. Their collective say usually runs through structures the franchisor agrees to, like the local advertising co-ops Papa Johns franchisees just voted to bring back. Korea is about to test what happens when the government writes that seat at the table into law.